Best Down Alternative Comforter 2023

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

Down comforters are fantastic, but they do have their drawbacks – namely, they cost more and can exacerbate allergies. In addition, some people find down to be unethical. Whatever someone’s reasons are for avoiding down, a down alternative comforter can be a great, well, alternative!

Down alternative comforters are hypoallergenic, contain polyester or some other synthetic alternative to down, and generally, cost less than down! However, deciding to go with a down alternative is just the beginning – customers then need to sift through the thousands of comforter options out there.

To make everyone’s buying process much easier, we put together our list of the five best down alternative comforters. There’s something here for everyone, so read on to find the best down alternative comforter!

Best Down Alternative Comforter

Best Down Alternative Comforters 2023: Our Video Roundup

Best Overall – Superior

Superior Solid White Down Alternative Comforter

Superior Solid White Down Alternative Comforter

Those who like the fluff and loft of down but struggle with allergies or want a warm comforter and can't pay for expensive down might want to take a look at the Superior Solid White Down Alternative Comforter.

Mattress Clarity Score
4.60 / 5 starstarstarstarstar
Read Full Review
Check Price

Accessories Details

Material
Material

Microfiber, Down

Financing
Financing

Not Available

Shipping Method
Shipping Method

Free shipping

Return Policy
Return Policy

Free returns

 

Superior - Best Overall Down Alternative ComforterWhen people are shopping for a comforter, many of them have an idea of what a comforter is supposed to look and feel like; specifically, they think comforters should be fluffy and warm. The issue with many down alternative comforters is that they don’t really promise the same insulating, cloud-like experience that one finds with down.

However, those who want the down experience without its drawbacks should take a look at the Superior Down Alternative Comforter. The Superior contains 77 ounces of polyester, down alternative fill with an exceptional amount of loft; looking at the comforter from the side, it really rises off the mattress in a nice way.

It also offers the warmth that one finds with many down comforters; lying underneath the Superior, most sleepers should feel insulated. At the same time, the comforter is quite breathable for a down alternative comforter, and it shouldn’t make sleepers too hot on those warmer nights.

The Superior offers the benefits of a down comforter without the drawbacks – what’s not to love?

What Makes the Superior Stand Out?

  • The comforter features a surprising amount of loft and fluff for a down alternative comforter.
  • The Superior has a microfiber shell and polyester fill that won’t trap allergens.
  • The comforter is sold for around $45 for a Full/Queen size, making it a very good value.

Read the full Superior comforter review.

Most Affordable – Utopia

Utopia Comforter

Utopia Comforter

If you're on the hunt for a high-quality comforter, Utopia is a good option to look at. It can be found on Amazon for a big discount and it feels soft and fluffy!

Check Price

Accessories Details

Material
Material

Microfiber

Financing
Financing

Not Available

Shipping Method
Shipping Method

Free shipping

 

A man rests on his arm using the Utopia Down Alternative comforterOne of the main reasons customers might be considering a down alternative comforter is their lower price; as I mentioned above, down alternative comforters are usually priced much lower than their down counterparts. Looking on Amazon, there are many cheap comforters, but their quality is sometimes questionable.

That is not the case with the Utopia Down Alternative Comforter, a great value pick that doesn’t skimp on quality. First off, in terms of price, the Utopia is currently sold for under $30 for a Queen size comforter – compare that with some of the $800 down comforters out there! Second, the Utopia offers some nice fluff and warmth, especially for a comforter of its price.

While the microfiber outer shell isn’t the softest, the Utopia works fantastically as a duvet insert; it even features duvet tabs at its corners. This allows us to tie the Utopia into a duvet cover, giving the outside of the comforter a much different feel.

Those who are working with an extremely tight budget and want a value, warm and fluffy comforter or duvet insert should take a look at the Utopia.

What Makes the Utopia Stand Out?

  • The Utopia is sold in multiple size and color options.
  • The comforter features a square, quilted pattern to help keep the polyester fill distributed evenly.

Best Cooling Comforter – ClimaBalance

ClimaBalance Down Alternative Comforter

ClimaBalance Down Alternative Comforter

In the end, the ClimaBalance comforter should be a fitting option for hot sleepers. However, it might not be the best option for those who want something warm and fluffy.

Mattress Clarity Score
4.40 / 5 starstarstarstarstar
Read Full Review
Check Price

Accessories Details

Material
Material

Microfiber

Financing
Financing

Not Available

Shipping Method
Shipping Method

Free shipping

Return Policy
Return Policy

Free returns

 

A man rubs his hand across the top of a white comforter.Big fluffy comforters can be a great match on those colder nights, but what about on those hotter nights? Well, that’s what the ClimaBalance Down Alternative Comforter is all about; it boasts some very interesting features that should be a big help on those balmier evenings.

The most noticeable feature on the ClimaBalance is the Climate Zone technology; a number of mesh squares are placed across the surface area of the comforter. These allow hot air to escape on warmer nights, allowing the body to cool, and they even work to warm the body on those warmer nights – it’s pretty amazing!

In addition, the ClimaBalance is simply a thinner down alternative comforter and is quite breathable overall; even in those areas that do not feature the mesh squares, there should still be a good amount of airflow. The company performed studies and found that users fell asleep more quickly and spent more time in REM sleep when using the ClimaBalance.

What Makes the Climabalance Stand Out?

  • The comforter comes in various sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, Large King, and California King.
  • The ClimaBalance is made from a material called Sensofill, a down alternative made to draw heat away from sleepers.

Read the full ClimaBalance review

Most Warm and Insulating – Chezmoi Micromink Sherpa

Chezmoi Micromink Sherpa

Chezmoi Micromink Sherpa

The Chezmoi Micromink Sherpa feels like soft mink, and can keep you warm during those colder months.

Check Price

Accessories Details

Material
Material

Polyester, Microfiber

Financing
Financing

Not Available

 

an up-close shot of a sherpa blanket showing its soft textureThere are hot sleepers, and then there are people who are basically walking ice cubes; they can never seem to get warm. Well, for that latter group, we’ve got the Chezmoi Micromink Sherpa Down Alternative Comforter – that’s a mouthful! This is one of the warmest comforters we’ve come across and should keep even the coldest sleepers warm on those chilly evenings.

The Chezmoi is a flippable down alternative comforter. On one side, it features soft micromink which is smooth and velvety; the other side is covered in a faux sherpa fleece that has the feeling of wool lining. Both sides have a soft comfortable feel, but sleepers can really decide which works best for them.

Whichever side they choose, people should be sleeping nice and warm under the Chezmoi – it also features a good amount of down alternative fill that, together with the micromink and sherpa fleece, makes it very insulating.|

What Makes the Chezmoi Stand Out?

  • The Chezomi features box stitching so that the inner fibers stay evenly dispersed.
  • The comforter comes as a set and includes two pillow shams made from the same.
  • The Chezmoi is very affordable and costs less than $50 for a Queen size comforter.

Most Eco-Friendly – Buffy Cloud

Buffy Cloud Comforter

Buffy Cloud Comforter

The Buffy is an eco-friendly comforter that features technology to fight overheating.

Mattress Clarity Score
4.80 / 5 starstarstarstarstar
Read Full Review
Check Price

Accessories Details

Material
Material

Tencel

Trial Period
Trial Period

100 nights

Warranty
Warranty

Lifetime limited warranty

Financing
Financing

Available

Shipping Method
Shipping Method

Free shipping minus HI and AK

Return Policy
Return Policy

Free returns

 

The Buffy Comforter PatternOne of the main reasons that people consider down alternative comforters is because, as I mentioned above, some shoppers find down to be unethical. Those people who are wanting the best comforter that is extra eco-friendly will want to hear about the Buffy comforter.

Like the other comforters on this list, the Buffy is free of down. However, what sets the Buffy apart is what type of down alternative fill that it features; instead of polyester, the Buffy contains fill made from recycled plastic. Shoppers who are more environmentally conscious should be impressed by this feature. The Buffy also contains eucalyptus fiber in its outer shell which has anti-inflammatory properties.

The Buffy also boasts decent loft for a down alternative comforter. Also, it is not the most breathable comforter, but should be a good match for those colder nights.

What Makes the Buffy Stand Out?

  • The outer shell of the Buffy is made from Tercel lyocell, a material made from wood pulp and eucalyptus.
  • The tercel lyocell has moisture wicking properties which is great for hot sleepers.

Read the full Buffy Cloud comforter review.

Honorable Mention – Saatva

Saatva Comforter

Saatva Comforter

This down alternative comforter is made with organic cotton and cloud-like and hypoallergenic down alternative.

Mattress Clarity Score
5.00 / 5 starstarstarstarstar
Read Full Review
Check Price

Accessories Details

Material
Material

Cotton, Lyocell, Down Alternative

Trial Period
Trial Period

45 nights

Warranty
Warranty

1-year limited warranty

Financing
Financing

Not Available

Shipping Method
Shipping Method

Free shipping

Return Policy
Return Policy

Free returns

 

A hand glides across the Saatva comforter

Saatva is known in the sleep space for making high-quality mattresses and sleep accessories and the Saatva comforter is no different. If you’re looking for a down alternative comforter that is soft, breathable, and great for year-round use, this comforter might be a great option for you.

The Saatva comforter is made from Fair Trade-certified cotton percale that has a thread count of 200, which makes it very breathable, and the comforter is very soft to the touch. The filling in the comforter is a mix of 3D down alternative fibers that help with softness, and lyocell, a eucalyptus-based material.

The comforter will likely feel nice and cozy on colder nights due to the filling, but the lower thread count will help keep heat from being trapped on the warmer nights.

What Makes the Saatva Stand Out?

  • The Saatva is machine washable and hypoallergenic.
  • The Saatva comes in three different sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, and King/California King.
  • The Saatva has corner loops so it can fit inside a duvet cover.

Read our full Saatva comforter review.

What’s the Difference Between Down and Down Alternative?

Down is a material that comes from underneath the feathers of ducks and geese. It traps heat well, so it allows for great insulation while also providing a soft and fluffy feel.

Down alternative is synthetic and usually contains polyester or polyester-like materials. Down alternative can have a soft and fluffy feel too, and is usually less expensive and easier to clean than down. Down alternatives are a great option if you’re allergic to down.

If you’re still confused about what’s best for you, check out our down vs. down alternative comparison.

Who Should Choose a Down Alternative Comforter?

There are a number of different types of sleepers who should consider a down alternative comforter – keep reading to see who a down alternative comforter is the best fit for.

  • People with allergies. Down is a material that can trap allergens such as dust mites and pollen. Because of this, many allergy sufferers complain that down comforters make them wake up with a stuffy nose and red eyes. While some down comforter producers claim their product is hypoallergenic, it is much safer to go with a down alternative. Down alternative comforters can be truly hypoallergenic and won’t exacerbate allergies.
  • Those who want to avoid down. Some down comforter makers try their best to source down as ethically as possible, many people find down to be downright unethical. Down alternative comforters only contain synthetic fill, so vegans and those who don’t want to use animal products can rest easy.
  • Shoppers who are on a budget. In general, down alternative comforters are more affordable than down comforters, so people who are on a tight budget are going to be better off with a down alternative comforter.
  • People who want something easy to clean. The majority of down comforters need to be taken to the dry cleaners to properly cleaned, but this is not the case with down alternative comforters. Most down alternative comforters can be washed and dried at home, making it much easier to keep them clean.

Summary

Anyone who thinks a down alternative comforter is a good choice should definitely consider one of these five options. They are all affordable, hypoallergenic, and much easier to maintain than a down comforter!

Comforter Best For
The Superior Best Overall
Utopia Most Affordable
ClimaBalance Best Cooling Comforter
Chezmoi Micromink Sherpa Most Warm and Insulating
Buffy Cloud Most Eco-Friendly

FAQs

What is a down alternative comforter?

Simply put, a down alternative comforter is a comforter that does not contain natural down fill - instead, down alternative comforters contain some kind of synthetic fill such as polyester.

What is the best down alternative comforter?

Out of the five down alternative comforters we have chosen, the Superior Down Alternative Comforter is our favorite - it offers many of the benefits of a down comforter but without the drawbacks. It is fluffy, and warm like many down comforters, but it is also hypoallergenic and more affordable.

Do down alternative comforters sleep hot?

It depends on the comforter, but some down alternative comforters can sleep hot. In general, down alternative fills are less breathable than down and, if the comforter has a heavy amount of fill and features a shell that is not breathable, it can make for a hot night of sleep.

Is down alternative better than down?

This really depends on what customers are looking for. For instance, if someone wants a hypoallergenic option that costs less and is easier to clean, a down alternative comforter will be better for them. On the other hand, if they want something very fluffy, warm, and breathable, down might be the better way to go.

Gravatar for Marten Carlson

Marten Carlson

Marten is the Lead Reviewer at Mattress Clarity. He is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and covers the mattress industry as well as sleep science news. He is specifically interested in the connection between sleep and overall health. Marten has written for media publications like Consequence of Sound and received a master’s degree in Film Studies from Emory University. He comes from Franklin, Indiana, and spends all the time he can writing, directing, and acting in films.